The New Cindy's Craft Co-Op
Welcome to Your Local Handmade Marketplace
"Because shopping here feels like a treasure hunt, it’s not just retail; it’s a community of makers pouring heart and soul into every piece".
Step inside 2330 West State Street in Olean, NY and discover a world where creativity lives on every shelf. Our craft co-op brings together the work of over 30 talented local artisans, each one adding their own magic touch to our collection of handmade treasures.
The Pet Event!
JOIN US Saturday, March 7th!
🐾 Pet Lovers, This One’s for You! 🐾
Calling all pet lovers! Stop by The New Cindy’s Craft Co-op on Saturday, March 7th, for a special Pet Event celebrating the furry members of your family. Shop our collection of one-of-a-kind, locally made pet gifts and products—perfect for treating your own pets or finding a unique gift for a fellow animal lover.
As a thank-you for shopping, everyone who purchases any pet product will receive a FREE pet safety sticker, helping alert fire departments that pets are inside your home. We’ll also be accepting donations for the Cattaraugus County SPCA, so you can give back to local animals in need while you shop.
Support local makers, spoil your pets, and make a difference—we can’t wait to see you there!
Cheers to 2 Years
We are kicking off our 3rd year at our new location!
The New Cindy’s Craft Co-Op is celebrating our third year in our new home, and we’d love for you to be part of the festivities. To say thank you for supporting handmade, heartfelt, and local creativity, shoppers can enjoy 10% off their purchase during our anniversary sale.
And because every good celebration needs a bit of delightful suspense, you can also enter to win an Easter basket overflowing with goodies while you’re here.
Come wander around, discover something wonderful, and celebrate three creative years with us. We can’t wait to see you.
Psychic Readings with Michael Crick!
The New Cindy's Craft Co-Op
Experience insightful and intuitive psychic readings with Michael Crick of Salamanca, NY, available at our shop on the 3rd Saturday of every month. Whether you’re seeking clarity, guidance, or a deeper understanding of what’s ahead, Michael’s readings offer a meaningful and personal experience you won’t want to miss.
Treat yourself to a moment of insight and connection; reserve your spot and see what the universe has in store for you.
Appointments fill quickly, so calling the store in advance to book your reading is highly encouraged.
See our News and Events for even more excitement around the store!
Stay Informed for Upcoming Events
"You'll enjoy the big selection, affordable prices, and the nicest people to help you choose what you're looking for! It's a fun shopping experience!"
- Mark Thompson
"Love love love this store!!! You can ALWAYS find something beautifully made, and the quality is great. Customer service is fantastic and prices are fair! Linda is especially wonderful."
- Brandi Cooperhaven
